Summary: Seventeen-year-old Bronwen Oliver has a theory that she was switched at birth. It's the only idea she can come up with that would explain why she's so totally out of place in her own family. When Jared Sondervan walks into her life, though, Bronwen thinks she's finally found where she belongs. He seems perfect for her- and she fits into his family the way she never can in her own. Then Jared proposes and Bronwen accepts, launching into planning a wedding when all her friends are mentally decorating their dorm rooms. Everything is moving so fast, but Jared is what Bronwen really wants.... right?
My thoughts: In the first few pages of this book, I didn't think I was going to like it. I'm glad I kept going, though, because it's turned into one of my favorite books this month.
I Now Pronounce You Someone Else is a light, fun read that surprised me by having quite a bit of substance to it.
The writing style is very casual and conversational. I felt like I could be listening to a friend telling me about her love life. Think Meg Cabot, with less, "well, like, totally!" I think the style really suits the story. As I read about Bronwen's experiences, I fell in love with her quirky sense of humor, her strong sense of self, and her vulnerablility. She's a girl who knows what she believes in, and she'll stand up for it. Even if it takes her a little while to work up the courage. I think I'm living under the delusion that she and I are friends now.
Not all the characters are so admirable, but they're all great. I think I have found a strong contender to beat Mrs. Bennet (Pride and Prejudice) for the title of "Most Annoying Fictional Mother Of All Time." Bronwen's mother is truly horrifying, without being evil. No wonder Bronwen has issues.
The variety of themes and issues touched on in this book is truly amazing. Off the top of my head, there's love, loss, family ties, knowing yourself, standing up for what you believe and what you want, forgiveness and growing up. It's the kind of book you can read over and over and get something new from it every time.
Several reviewers have mentioned that the romance between Bronwen and Jared is so rushed, they couldn't get into it. I think in some ways that's really the point. They're young, and they're getting in too deep, too fast. The reader is supposed to feel a bit uncomfortable with it all, just like Bronwen does. But for my money, I actually liked the romance. I though Jared was very sweet and funny, that he and Bronwen were a good fit together.
Final word: (5/5) One of those rare books that manages to be both fluffy and insightful. Took me a while to get into the story, but I like it more the more I think about it.
Content: Sex is mentioned, but handled in a way I would be totally comfortable with offering to young teens.
About Erin McCahan: "On my fourth day on the job, I had such a fit of nervous laughter on the phone – having to use the word enema three times in a scripted response to new patients – that I got booted from the receptionist’s desk to the insurance office where I just typed forms for weeks on end." -Borrowed from the
bio on her website.
Second opinions:
Steph Su Reads (4/5)
YA Reads (3/5)
Cornucopia of Reviews (C)
Books by Their Cover (B+)
Reflections With Coffee
Did I miss yours?